Church Insurance2025-04-03T06:12:10-04:00

Church
Insurance
Quotes

Church Insurance Quotes

google rating and reviews graphic
fearnow bbb badge
angies list a rating badge
google rating and reviews graphic
fearnow bbb badge
angies list a rating badge

Quotes from 350+ Carriers:

progressive insurance
auto owners insurance
travelers insurance
nationwide insurance
liberty mutual insurance
allstate insurance

Save up to 37% with Fearnow Insurance

Most churches have activities that extend far beyond their normal Sunday Service.  The reality is that every church is susceptible to a lawsuit by its members, guests or other individuals.  No matter what precautions you may have in place, accidents happen, property gets damaged, people get hurt, liability issues occur, thefts take place, and much more.  For the many unavoidable situations or accidents that happen, you need a great insurance program that will protect your entire church, even when off campus.  Being an active member in our church helps us to better understand some of the needs of the local church, while giving us a bird’s eye view to help find gaps in coverage and offer solutions in the most economical way, while representing the premier providers of insurance for religious institutions.  Our ability to provide quality insurance that meets the unique needs of your church is what sets Fearnow Insurance, Inc. apart from other agencies.  We are honored to serve churches locally in Brandon, Tampa, Seffner, the State of Florida and Nationally.

What Our Customers Say

Jean Rodriguez with FearNow Insurance has done an amazing job for our church over the past several years. I am always so impressed by her commitment to the customer and the excellent service provided. She is committed to getting the best insurance for the best price. She is never too busy to take your call or get back to you as soon as possible. Jean, thank you for all that you do!
Jeanie McAlister
18:59 27 Aug 25
Kayla Peel is amazing! She navigated a tough scenario for me and got me an amazing rate! Kudos to her and this company for all they do for their customers!
Nate Hudson
13:48 25 Aug 25
I was very pleased with Lydia. She was very patient, helpful, professional, informative and knowledgeable with a sweet personality. She needs transaction and effortlessly. I am thankful.
Lydia Calderon
12:27 22 Aug 25
Brian Fearnow helped this newbie find a suitable and affordable commercial insurance policy. He was patient, helpful, and quick to respond throughout the process. I would recommend 100%!
Elizabeth Gregory
19:52 21 Aug 25
I have received excellent service every time I requested it, 100% recommended.Thank you from D R CORNER CONSTRUCTION CORP
JOSE DANIEL RODRIGUEZ
15:38 20 Aug 25
The commercial team at Fearnow Insurance is always so helpful. Yailyn found savings and always helps answer my questions. She is quick to respond and is full of knowledge. I would recommend Fearnow Insurance to all of my friends and family. We have worked with Fearnow Insurance for over five years and have been so happy with our choice of insurance brokers.
Lanai Lifestyles
14:19 20 Aug 25
I was having trouble with trying to download pictures to send to my insurance provider. They referred me to Kayla. I couldn’t get a better person to help me with my difficulties. She was very calm and walked me through different situations. I had hung up to try them to see them work. While I was trying them she sent another way to get them done. It worked. She went above and beyond to solve my problem. She is an asset represented Fearnow at a high level and made my day.
Gregory Jackson
22:07 04 Aug 25
Joseph Boyle made it fast and easy to understand. He was very efficient at securing the most reasonable quote for me. I highly recommend him.
Henry G
17:51 16 Jul 25
OUTSTANDING COMPANY! I would give it 10 stars if it was an option! We had been getting ripped off by our FORMER insurance company for many years. A friend at work recommend this Fearnow Insurance and Mr. Joe Boyle specifically. Within a few days, Joe not only found us a much better homeowners policy which is saving us over $5000.00 on our premium, he walked us through both policies (car and home) and made some MUCH NEEDED adjustments to our coverages and deductibles to ensure we are covered in case of an emergency. They are definitely experts in this field. We have never felt this comfortable about our insurance coverages and what we are spending on it. This was such an easy process and it's wild how fast we already have new policies. Thank you Joe Boyle!I will definitely be recommending this company to everyone I know.
Marvin Johnson
19:52 08 Jul 25
Great experience. Joe has been working hard to find me great coverage at a good price after my original policy kept increasing. He was able to do that, found me better coverage at a much better rate. I appreciate him working so hard! Highly recommend.
Kenny Collins
19:00 03 Jul 25

The Fearnow Agency Advantage

  • We work for you, not the insurance carriers, to ensure your claims are processed efficiently and are paid out quickly.
  • Unlike a single-company agency, we have access to over 100 carriers, so we’re never limited in the services we can provide you.
  • We can save you up to 37% in insurance cost, or get better coverage for the same cost.
  • We always provide full disclosure of plan inclusions and exclusions.
  • We offer customized plans tailored specifically to your needs, instead of forcing you into a pre-packaged solution that won’t really work for you.
  • Our agents are continuously training, so they stay the leading experts in their field.

Revelation 4:11 Thou art worthy, O Lord, to receive glory and honor and power: for thou hast created all things, and for thy pleasure they are and were created.

Coverage Offerings

General Liability
Professional Liability
Property Coverage
Employee Benefits
Employment Practices Liability
Group Health

Auto Liability
Cyber Liability Coverage
Management Liability Coverage
Equipment Breakdown
Workers’ Compensation
AND More…

Umbrella
Student Accident Coverage
Abuse Liability Coverage
Crime Coverage
Religious Enhancements

Local & Family Owned

Offices serving the local Tampa, FL and Wilson, NC areas for almost 30 years!

Competitive pricing nationally with world-class customer service!

Do we really need sexual abuse coverage?

Any organization that works with children has the potential to be accused of a crime that is sexual in nature.  It doesn’t matter if nothing really happened, an accusation can be made, and the church would then have to defend itself.  Sexual Misconduct is one of the most serious financial exposures facing church/religious organizations.  It is an unfortunate fact that this is a necessary coverage for church insurance in Florida.

What steps should be taken then?

Always make sure that there are at least two people with a child at all times. It is just best to never be alone with a child so there is nothing for others to speculate.  Run background checks on anyone working with children, and make new members wait at least a year before they are allowed to work with children.  Make sure to have a written plan to handle allegations, and have polices in place that address the church’s stance and procedures in the handbook.  Have sexual abuse prevention training interviews with new hires and volunteers.

Why Fearnow Insurance, Inc. for church insurance?

Christian Agency – We understand the ministry and want to be your trusted partner with YOUR BEST interest in mind.

Church Specialist – We understand that every dollar counts.  Proper coverage is a must, while also being insured with a reputable insurance company.

Amazing Products – We represent premier providers of insurance for nonprofits, and have many different options to create specialized policies tailored to your specific needs.  We turn your problems into solutions.

The Fearnow Team – We understand the value of working as a team to provide extraordinary service and strive for your 100% satisfaction.

True Partners – We share some of the same goals, to impact the kingdom and make disciples.  We want to help provide the best coverage, at the best price, so your church can be the most effective.

Robbie Fearnow

Robbie Fearnow  

Brian Fearnow

Brian Fearnow  

Church Insurance

Romans 12:2 – “And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what [is] that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God.”

Independent Home Insurance Agent

2 Timothy 3:16-16 – “All scripture [is] given by inspiration of God, and [is] profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness.”

collossians

Colossians 3:23 – “And whatever you do, do it heartily, as to the Lord and not to men.”

It Is Our Ministry To Serve The Ministry…

As fellow Christians, we believe an area of our ministry is to provide a service of Insurance.

Being actively involved in our local church gives us a bird’s eye view into specific needs of the church, and its distinct ministries.

As Licensed Insurance Agents, we also understand the coverages needed by churches and their schools.  We understand the importance of having a trusted partner and honest adviser to negotiate on the church’s behalf.  This is our calling of servant-ship for God’s church.

We will provide upfront, honest and professional service through experience, education, coverage offerings, and carrier options.  We believe we are able to truly serve the church’s insurance needs, and help provide proper protection at the best rates, for the church and all involved.

Thank You and God Bless,
Brian & Robbie Fearnow

Church Insurance | Fast & Easy Quote | Trusted for 30 Years

Church Insurance Quote from Fearnow Insurance. Quality business protection that saves you money. 30 Years of serving Tampa, Brandon, Seffner area

Service Type: Business Insurance

Price: $$

Currency: USD