Fearnow Insurance | Property | Vehicle | Business | Life & Health2021-10-11T12:33:47-04:00

What can we
help you with?

Auto Insurance


Ship Insurance Boat Insurance


home-icon home insurance


health-Insurance heart-icon




fearnow bbb badge

Google Rating
Based on 309 reviews

I recently purchased a new vehicle and spoke with Ms. Michelle Mohler regarding switching over my auto insurance. Michelle was very friendly, knowledgeable and quick to handle my requirements. Additionally, she was able to help me reduce my property insurance by making several suggested changes to my policy. Overall, a great experience with this dedicated insurance agent.
Mike Naugle
13:31 15 Jan 22
Joe Boyle is amazing. He helped us get home owners insurance and flood insurance on our new home. He is very knowledgeable, super responsive, and a true professional.We couldn't have gotten this house without him. He went out of his way to answer any questions that any party involved had. If there was a 10 star rating I would choose that. Thanks a lot Joe! We truly appreciate you!
Josh Thomas
20:16 12 Jan 22
I highly recommend Fearnow insurance. They will find you the lowest quote you can possibly get. I have had plenty of representatives help me with my insurance there but if you ask for Matt he will be sure to go out and behind for you and find exactly what you are looking for!! He totally treats you like family. You Can’t go wrong with them!
18:48 11 Jan 22
Joseph Went beyond callTo make sure I got decent coverage and a great rate.Even assisted with the cancellation of my previous policy.
Tommy Tarbox
22:11 03 Jan 22
My name is Hope and I had the pleasure of speaking with Mr. Joe Boyle. Joe thank you for my auto quote and the through explanation of benefits and what Progressive has to offer.Joe, you relieved my fears about car insurance for my daughter. I have been in fear for over 6 months and TODAY, I finally feel relieved. I hired an attorney, and I still was not fully satisfied with their answer. No more tears, after today. Joe, I thank God that you were on the other end of the call.Joe, you were my Angel today. Please continue to do great work, great customer service and thanks for letting me vent without interruptions.In my line of work, I hope our paths never cross (Process Server) "God in me, Loves you"Hope G.
Hope Goodwin
18:17 03 Jan 22
I had the pleasure of working with Joe at Fearnow Insurance. He was resourceful, helpful, and a great communicator. Joe went above and beyond to help me as his client. I would recommend contacting Joe to assist you in finding the best insurance plan!
Laura Watson
23:01 29 Dec 21
Joe Boyle was excellent. He is very knowledgeable & was able to help us save almost $1000 per year on our auto insurance. I would recommend this company to anyone looking to cut their insurance expenses.Fearnow & Joe Boyle strike again. My home owners insurance was not going to be renewed in April. Joe was able to get me not only a $700 a year savings but better coverage.Also my auto renewal went down another $800 this year. Amazing!!!
Kim Aldridge
13:07 20 Dec 21
I requested a Homeowners Insurance quote online and my agent Taunya contacted me and within minutes I had a brand new policy with a nearly 40% decrease in premium from my existing Insurance Company. Taunya was professional, knowledgeable, patient and efficient. She exceeded my expectations and made the process seamless and effortless. I would highly recommend Fearnow Insurance to my friends and family without hesitation! Thank you again for such a wonderful experience:)
Dorothy Aiken
00:11 13 Nov 21
Joe with Fearnow was great. Got us a great rate on auto and home. We are saving just over $100 a month just in our auto from our previous carrier USAA. Everything was done by phone and electronic. Fast service, seamless communication, great value. If you want to save money, highly recommend calling Joe for all your insurance needs!
17:26 05 Nov 21
I work with Lydia Bobek on my homeowners insurance that had unexpectedly been canceled. She was quick to respond and help me secure a new policy in just a few quick hours. Excellent customer service!
Samson Lewis
21:31 28 Oct 21


You have worked long and hard for all of the things you have in your life – your home, your car, your business. That is why it is important for you to do everything you can to properly protect the time, money, and emotional investments you have made into these things by working with our independent insurance company.

Accidents happen every day without rhyme or reason.  In a moment, your life can drastically change.  With the right insurance coverage, however, you can minimize the damage these accidents have on your life.

  • We work for you, not the insurance carriers, to ensure your claims are processed efficiently and are paid out quickly.

  • Unlike a single-company agency, we have access to over 100 carriers, so we’re never limited in the services we can provide you.

  • We can save you up to 37% in insurance cost, or get better coverage for the same cost.

  • We always provide full disclosure of plan inclusions and exclusions.

  • We offer customized plans tailored specifically to your needs, instead of forcing you into a pre-packaged solution that won’t really work for you.

  • Our agents are continuously training, so they stay the leading experts in their field.

Testimonials from Local Businesses

After being with the same agent for 13 years, I decided to switch to Fearnow for several reasons.  1) Robbie & Brian Fearnow helped me save over $20,000 per year on my Commercial Auto insurance alone.  (I didn’t believe it until I received my first monthly bill).  2) They are professional, friendly and efficient.  I’m saving over $30,000 per year between my Homeowners’, Personal Auto, Commercial Auto, General Liability and Umbrella policies. Couldn’t be happier!

President: Micah O Valladares , Google Review
In more than 50 years of doing business in Tampa, the Olin Mott Tire Company believes that the Fearnow Insurance associates have met our needs better, provided better coverage at a better price than any other insurer.  They are a true business partner.
Olin Mott , Olin Mott Tire Company
I work for Hoffman Electrical and we have always used Fearnow for our General Liability insurance but recently had them quote our Commercial Auto and several other products we need for our business. They saved us about $20k on just the commercial auto alone, not to mention our agent Monica found all of the gaps in equipment that was not covered with our old auto insurance and brought it to our attention, now we feel confident that the business is completely covered and feel as though we got the best rates we could possible receive.  They are so knowledgeable and friendly, and they make us feel comfortable in using all of the services they provide.  We would highly recommend them to any business owner.
Keri Ricci , Hoffman Electrical

Working with Fearnow Insurance has been a pleasurable experience.  Not only did they keep me informed of every step of the new policy process, but they handled it with ease and experience.  And, to top it off they were able to provide me with wind protection in Hillsborough County!!  Fearnow Insurance set up everything so easily, that I was able to concentrate on building up my business.

Craig Laquerre , Giovanis’s Brick Oven Pizza, Valrico, FL

They made the process simple and hassle-free by doing the shopping for us.  He was prompt, thorough, and knowledgeable.  We will be bringing all our insurance to Fearnow Insurance in the future!

Panther Technologies , Tampa, FL

Proudly Certified

fearnow certifications

Contact Us
Request a Quote