Easy Quote Process & Personalized Service

Thank you for your interest in our independent insurance company located in Seffner, Florida.  The staff at Fearnow Insurance takes great pride in our ability to provide you with the best insurance policies to fit your exact needs.  Your satisfaction and happiness are very important to us.  That is why we also provide free quotes on all of the coverage options we have available.

Trusted Service

Fearnow Insurance
Based on 150 reviews
Greatly appreciate Joe at Fearnow Insurance! He has helped us with multiple homeowner's policies and now our auto policy. He is professional, prompt and knowledgeable.
Mike P.
Joe is a total rock star!!! He helped me out with auto and homeowners insurance. CALL HIM TODAY!!!
Debra N.
Fearnow Insurance is the best. Everyone there is great. My most recent experience was with Taunya Gaddie, a true professional. If everyone performed their job as she does, what a world we would have.
Raymond H.
The staff here at Fearnow Insurance are some of the kindest and friendliest employees I have encountered. They will be truthful and let you know why a quote comes back higher than expected and work with you to get the necessary requirements to bring that quote back down.
Tela W.
Quick, efficient & straight to the point while answering every inquiry honestly & in great detail. Open & up front , very easy to work with. Would recommend to friends!
Eric S.
So my favorite for a million years, Matt, asked for a review! Whaaattt??? If we’re being totally honest, he wants me to tell you how much I love him! Well, my dear brother and now friend, I do love you! Most fun you will ever have handling ALL of your insurance needs! Call Fearnow NOW! (teehee) Personal lines, commercial lines. THE BEST IN FLORIDA!
Carlene Ann S.
Taunya Gaddie is so great to work with. She listened to all the issues my son was having with his insurance. She patiently explained everything and all of the options coming up with an awesome solution. Thanks so much!
Michael B.
I called Joe Boyle at Fearnow insurance after being rejected by several companies because my newly purchased house, a resale, had an 'old' roof. It didn't look old to Joe, and he researched it until he found a permit filed, proving the roof was less than 15 years old. Then the company he chose decided not to accept the application for unstated reasons, and he went looking again. After 2 days he found another company, with a similar price, who could bind the policy. Joe is like a bulldog, grabbing you by the leg and not letting go until he finds a policy that will work for you. He called me back every time. No detail was overlooked. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
gino B.
This people are great humble and down to earth. They have always taken care off me hands down, I have both my personal and company's insurance whit them. Especially Suzy Filep that's my go to girl does an amazing job taking calls returning email etc. Just and overall great service. I have recommended them and will continue to do so hands down.
Adonai's Warrior Transportation I.
I work for Hoffman Electrical and we have always used Fearnow for our General Liability insurance, Worker's Comp and Commercial auto. Emily, Suzy, Sara, Ken and the whole Fearnow group are all amazing to work with. They are responsive and treat us like family not just a customer. Very professional and knowledgable!! I would recomment them to any business owner.
Keri R.

Insurance or Service Desired:

When you work with our agents, you can rest easy knowing you are always going to receive personal, one-on-one help with all of your insurance needs.  Completing our free online quote form provides us with the information we need to quickly get started on your insurance policy.  If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.

We take the time to listen to your needs and desires so that we can find the perfect coverage for you.  Your total satisfaction is our number one priority.  By providing us with the correct information for your insurance quote, we are able to quote you all of the major insurance companies located in Florida to ensure you are receiving the best insurance coverage, at the most affordable rate available.  Our company has built a reputation for client satisfaction, so feel free to send us any questions or concerns you might have.

You have the added benefit of working with a professional insurance advisor who understands your needs when you work with our insurance agency.  Finding the right policy is only the beginning.  We carry all of the major insurance companies in Florida, which allows us to compare rates and coverages to make sure that you are completely satisfied with your insurance policy.  Enjoy smooth sailing throughout the entire insurance coverage process by working with our team every step of the way.

Contact us for more information about how you can take advantage of our free insurance quotes.  We are helping individuals throughout Florida find the best deals on the coverage they need.