Nonprofit Insurance2025-04-03T06:16:06-04:00

Nonprofit
Insurance
Quotes

Nonprofit Insurance Quotes

google rating and reviews graphic
fearnow bbb badge
angies list a rating badge
google rating and reviews graphic
fearnow bbb badge
angies list a rating badge

Quotes from 350+ Carriers:

progressive insurance
auto owners insurance
travelers insurance
nationwide insurance
liberty mutual insurance
allstate insurance

Save up to 37% with Fearnow Insurance

Are you a nonprofit organization that needs insurance, but aren’t sure where to get a good quality nonprofit insurance policy at an affordable price? Just like for-profit operations, nonprofits need to be fully insured to financially protect themselves against unforeseen and unexpected covered events. Here at Fearnow, our agents can help you create an insurance plan that will help mitigate the costs associated with certain weather events, car accidents, on-property injuries, certain types of lawsuits, and workers’ compensation.

Types of Non-Profit Insurance Coverage

  • Business Owners Insurance
  • Commercial Car Insurance
  • Cyber Risk Insurance
  • Employment Practices Liability
  • ERISA Fidelity Insurance
  • Errors and Omissions
  • Fidelity and Crime Insurance
  • Fiduciary Liability
  • General Liability
  • Kidnap and Ransom Insurance
  • Nonprofit Directors and Officers Liability
  • Workers Compensation

What Our Customers Say

Joseph and Kayla went above and beyond to find the best rates for home and auto insurance. They stayed in constant communication and made the process very easy. 10/10 recommend Fearnow insurance!
Steven
22:32 11 Sep 25
Helped me find good policies in my budget.Madrianne was very helpful,kind and so easy to work with.... She is GREAT !!
Eric Hopkins
14:49 09 Sep 25
Jean Rodriguez with Fearnow Insurance has been such a blessing for Catholic Youth Soccer, Inc. Since we became a federally recognized nonprofit, she has been fully committed to making sure we are properly protected. Jean’s customer service is amazing—she is attentive, knowledgeable, and always goes the extra mile.Thanks to Jean’s support, CYS has the peace of mind to focus on serving families in our community through faith-based youth soccer. I highly recommend Jean and Fearnow Insurance!CYS is a huge fan of Jean's!!!!!!!
Patrick Poland
20:49 05 Sep 25
Jean Rodriguez, went above and beyond to help me out with my policy . I have a health situation, and she resolved the issue. I appreciate the fact that she kept me informed, and cares about her Clients. Thank you!
Manuel Campoamor III
20:48 05 Sep 25
Lydia in auto and Joe in Life insurance are fantastic ! Excellent customer service , quick responses to inquiries, above and beyond enthusiasm and attention to detail. Highly recommend this Insurance agency.
Grace Rhymes
17:36 04 Sep 25
Joseph was great to work with. He was knowledgeable, communicative, and answered all my questions! He also saved me and my family hundreds of dollars while still keeping great insurance on two vehicles. Good bye Geico! Thank you Fearnow team!
Lorenzo Laporte
21:46 03 Sep 25
I had a great pleasure to work with Joe. Answered to all my questions (I had a lot) and found the best price for my home insurance. Would recommend to check these guys when you are renewing your policy
Andy S
20:34 03 Sep 25
Mr. Joseph was very professional and knows what he is doing.He is very knowledgeable about the needs of the customers and takes time to explain for your understanding.He is very quick in responding to emails and questions.Thank you for your assistance.
Daniel Otu-Jireh
18:38 01 Sep 25
Love dealing with Fearnow, they take care of all my insurance needs. Thank you Joe!
Garrett Norris
18:08 29 Aug 25
I would give our agent, Jean Rodriguez at 5 Stars for sure! She is very knowledgeable about our coverage and always very helpful in answering questions when I have them. She is quick to respond to phone calls and emails! Would highly recommend her for your insurance needs!
Christina Wyant
19:03 28 Aug 25

The Fearnow Agency Advantage

  • We work for you, not the insurance carriers, to ensure your claims are processed efficiently and are paid out quickly.
  • Unlike a single-company agency, we have access to over 100 carriers, so we’re never limited in the services we can provide you.
  • We can save you up to 37% in insurance cost, or get better coverage for the same cost.
  • We always provide full disclosure of plan inclusions and exclusions.
  • We offer customized plans tailored specifically to your needs, instead of forcing you into a pre-packaged solution that won’t really work for you.
  • Our agents are continuously training, so they stay the leading experts in their field.

Most auto policies are for six months to a year. Your insurance carrier will notify you by mail when it’s time to renew the policy and to pay your premium.

An auto insurance policy is comprised of six different kinds of coverage: Bodily Injury, Personal Injury Protection (Medical Payments), Property Damage Liability, Collision, Comprehensive, and Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist Coverage. Each coverage is priced separately.

Business Owners Insurance

Business owner’s insurance is also known as BOP insurance. It offers property protection and liability coverage for your nonprofit organization. It helps cover customers and visitors if they are injured on the property, and it helps protect your buildings if they are damaged during a covered event. Additionally, this type of coverage may pay for items such as debris removal and loss of income due to a covered event.

Commercial Car Insurance

If you use vehicles, like cars, vans, trucks, and buses, for your nonprofit, you’ll need a commercial car insurance policy. Commercial car insurance helps financially protect you if you are operating a business vehicle for business purposes and get into a car accident. Coverages that can be included in commercial car insurance include collision, comprehensive, roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and liability.

Cyber Risk Insurance

If you keep employee and customer data on a computer or on the Internet, this insurance helps protect you if you experience a data breach. This insurance may provide notifications for all individuals involved in the breach, credit report monitoring, and help with securing your equipment and records.

Local & Family Owned

Offices serving the local Tampa, FL and Wilson, NC areas for almost 30 years!

Competitive pricing nationally with world-class customer service!

Employment Practices Liability

If you have employees at your nonprofit, you need employment practices liability coverage. This insurance helps protect you against claims of wrongful termination, workplace harassment, retaliation, and discrimination. These types of accusations and lawsuits can be extremely expensive, therefore, it’s best to have an insurance policy to help mitigate the costs.

ERISA Fidelity Insurance

ERISA fidelity insurance is a great idea if you offer employee benefits packages, including 401ks. This type of insurance protects you if funds are lost through misdeeds, which include fraud, theft, lying, larceny, and embezzlement.

Professional Liability/ Errors and Omissions

Does your nonprofit sell products or services? If you do, you’ll probably need an errors and omissions policy, which is often referred to as professional liability insurance. This type of insurance helps financially protect you against real and perceived mistakes that accidentally cost your client money to harm your client’s professional or personal reputation.

Fidelity and Crime Insurance

While every business wants to believe their employees are honest and trustworthy, that’s not always the case. Fidelity and crime insurance are designed to help financially protect you if an employee steals money, equipment, or records. It also helps in instances of forgery, fraud, and the destruction of company property.

General Liability

General liability insurance is a good idea for all nonprofits. This insurance helps pay for customer injuries and/or property damage and injuries resulting from advertisements for the nonprofit. This type of insurance is especially useful if you host a lot of events or fundraisers.

Kidnap and Ransom Insurance

Kidnapping and ransom insurance are beneficial if you send your employees overseas where kidnapping for ransom is common. It may also help in instances of extortion and illegal detention of your employees.

Non-Profit Directors and Officers Liability

Non-profit directors’ and officers’ liability are designed to help financially protect you in the event your executives are presented with litigation from vendors, competitors, government regulators, donors or sponsors, and even employees. It helps ensure that you can maintain your mission and protect your executives’ and board members’ personal assets from forfeiture due to lawsuits.

Workers Compensation

Workers’ compensation helps pay for the medical care of employees who get injured on the job. This includes if your employee needs urgent care, a family doctor, a specialist, and/or a hospital stay.

Non-Profit Insurance with Fearnow

If you own a nonprofit organization, we can help you find all the insurance you need to help protect yourself in case of a covered weather disaster, fire, theft, car accidents, embezzlement, cyber-attacks, and even fraud and omissions claims against your business. Our agents will also answer all your questions and help create a business insurance package that meets your needs and your budget.

To learn more about our insurance policies for nonprofit organizations, give us a call at 813-689-8878.