We Are Fearnow Insurance

Our independent insurance agency has the experience and personnel necessary to fulfill our promise to our customers with efficient customer service, a caring attitude, and a vast knowledge that sets us apart from other Florida insurance agencies, and helps us meet our client’s insurance needs.

Whether our customers are in need of Personal Insurance, Business Insurance, Health Insurance, or Life Insurance, our specialists are here to provide guidance and service.  Additionally, the insurance carriers we represent rely on our integrity, knowledge of their products, and our commitment to serving our customers to the fullest extent.  This is what helps us keep our customers happy and their assets protected.  If you need to get life insurance, or any other type of insurance coverage, you can count on our team to find the right coverage to fit your budget and your needs.

Additionally, we believe that our community is very important, and that our company is privileged to be a part of it.  We believe in giving back to the community with our involvement and membership in various areas, including the Chamber of Commerce, youth sports, and the annual fundraising golf tournament to benefit the Joshua House.

Although our primary office is located in Seffner, Florida, our insurance company is capable of writing just about any type of insurance policy throughout the State of Florida.  We can also service individuals and businesses across the United States.

Fearnow Insurance

Our Mission Statement

To our employees, our customers, and our carriers:  It is our job to understand your needs and fulfill your expectations.  “Trust in the LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.  In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths.” – Proverbs 3:5-6

What Our Customers Say

OUTSTANDING COMPANY! I would give it 10 stars if it was an option! We had been getting ripped off by our FORMER insurance company for many years. A friend at work recommend this Fearnow Insurance and Mr. Joe Boyle specifically. Within a few days, Joe not only found us a much better homeowners policy which is saving us over $5000.00 on our premium, he walked us through both policies (car and home) and made some MUCH NEEDED adjustments to our coverages and deductibles to ensure we are covered in case of an emergency. They are definitely experts in this field. We have never felt this comfortable about our insurance coverages and what we are spending on it. This was such an easy process and it's wild how fast we already have new policies. Thank you Joe Boyle!I will definitely be recommending this company to everyone I know.
Marvin Johnson
19:52 08 Jul 25
Great experience. Joe has been working hard to find me great coverage at a good price after my original policy kept increasing. He was able to do that, found me better coverage at a much better rate. I appreciate him working so hard! Highly recommend.
Kenny Collins
19:00 03 Jul 25
Is it even possible to submit a 5 million star review of sales agent, Mr. Joseph Boyle with Fearnow Insurance Inc ? Mr. Boyle is a highly skilled professional and even more remarkable has exceptional interpersonal qualities: very congenial and displays highly caring empathy.In my own case, I recently received a renewal policy correspondence from my former insurance provider indicating that I would be paying over three times as much for car insurance because I purchased a new all electric vehicle. After an in office consultation with Mr. Boyle, he was able to search for a bundled alternative that ended up saving me a considerably large sum of money.If you are considering changes in your insurance coverages, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Joseph Boyle with Fearnow Insurance Inc. You will be very happy with the results.
William Rind
17:44 03 Jul 25
Kayla Peel worked diligently on my issue. She has gone above and beyond with my claim making sure I was always in the know as to what the next steps were on getting my insurance paperwork corrected. Kayla was super pleasant to engage with whether it be by phone, text or email. She was kind, polite and very understanding. She definitely is very detailed oriented and seems to be a great asset to Fernow insurance. She made sure I was well taken care of. If I could give more than 5 stars I would have given her 100 more ⭐️.
Joanne Amaro
12:24 27 Jun 25
Joseph Boyle is very personable and caring. He worked hard to find the right homeowners insurance policy for me taking price and coverage into consideration. I am confident I have found a great insurance agent that will continue to assist me year after year. If you have ever considered shopping your current policy, I would highly recommend giving Joe a call!!!
Lizabeth Pierce
00:47 29 May 25
Joe did an excellent job helping select the right policy for me quick and easy process thanks joe
Creed Fury
19:53 28 May 25
Thank you Matthew Wink for your awesome service with my homeowners insurance every year a true blessing to have with great company thanks again.
Jermaine Miller
19:31 28 May 25
BIG THANKS to Matt Wink for the support on my new truck. He's always been very helpful and pleasant to work with.
Lenny Campbell
16:07 28 May 25
I just wanted to thank Madrienne James at Fearnow for her outstanding service. She helped us save thousands on our insurance and I cannot thank her enough for her efficiency and hard work. I would recommend Fearnow to everyone!
Karen O'Malley
19:08 21 May 25
I've been a customer of Fearnow for about a year now...I started out with one home insurance policy with Fearnow and now I've transferred over all my policies to them. Joe has been incredible in helping me find the best prices for all my properties. He is very responsive to all my emails and questions and most importantly he is very thorough with everything. He doesn't miss a thing ! I feel confident in knowing that I am in good hand with Joe at Fearnow Ins.
Mindy
18:17 15 May 25
‹
›

The History of Our Insurance Agency

Fearnow Insurance, Inc. was created in 1991 by Kenneth Fearnow as a multi-line independent insurance agency, and soon after, our company began to grow rapidly.  In 1992, thanks to the growth of the agency, Ken’s wife, Susan, joined him in the business.

The agency has enjoyed continued growth throughout the years with an experienced, quality staff in our Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and Employee Benefits departments.  With a deep belief in continuing insurance education courses, including the Certified Insurance Counselor program, we are able to provide our customers with the knowledge and service they deserve.

Our agency was honored by winning the 2003 Greater Brandon Chamber of Commerce Small Business of the Year Award in our category and was one of the three finalists in 2002.  We look forward to continuing our commitment and service to our customers in our impressive 5,000 square foot building, which was completed for us in May 2004.

Contact us for more information about our many insurance services and how we can help provide coverage to individuals and businesses across the State of Florida.

Insuring Everything Important to You

There are many different types of insurance available from our independent insurance company in Seffner, Florida.  That is why the team at Fearnow Insurance wants to help you make the smartest choices when it comes to what type of coverage you should buy, as well as which carriers you should buy from.  We handle all of your personal insurance needs as part of our commitment to excellence, and use our access to multiple A-rated, admitted carriers to find you the best coverage for the most affordable price.  Just fill out our questionnaire and we will have a response to you within one business day.  If you need a quote now, and it is during our hours of operation, feel free to give us a call.

Take a look below at some of the different insurance services we provide, including information about auto insurance, homeowners’ insurance, and life insurance.  Then let one of our helpful agents discuss your needs with you so you can find the best options for you, your family, and your assets.  Additionally, make sure you take advantage of our free quotes.

An Independent Agency that Represents Many A+ Rated Carriers

Fearnow Insurance is an independent insurance agency that represents many A+ rated carriers. We advise you of coverages you might need and give you the options, tailor made your policies, to best fit your needs and give you the best possible price. Fearnow Insurance can serve all your insurance needs, home, auto, business, life, flood, boat, and even payroll services. Don’t delay call Fearnow Insurance today at 813-981-7862.